The majority of women worry about the appearance of their eyes. Fine lines and wrinkles can make you look older than you are, while dark circles and eye bags can make it obvious that you’re tired and stressed. Of course, everyone wants to erase these telltale signs, but your regular moisturizer isn’t enough to do it. It takes a specialized product that can best address the specific concerns of your eye area. That product is an eye cream.

One of the leading makers of eye products is Olay. With their decades of experience and cutting-edge research in skincare technology, they’ve come up with a slew of eye creams and gels. Each one is specially formulated to give your delicate undereye skin TLC that’s second to none. We’ve taken the five top-selling Olay eye creams and analyzed what they can do for you.

5 Best Olay Eye Creams

The Olay Eyes product range is so vast that it can get confusing. While all of them deliver hydration, each has dedicated ingredients that make it more effective for a particular problem. Whether you’re most concerned about signs of aging or signs of fatigue, there’s one that answers your need.

  Product Available Size Key Ingredient Benefit Fragrance Price  
Olay Eyes Ultimate Eye Cream 13 mL (0.4 fl oz) Vitamin B3, Amino Peptide, Pigments For dark circles, wrinkles, and puffiness Fragrance-free $39.95 Buy on Amazon
Olay Eyes Brightening Eye Cream 15 mL (0.5 fl oz) Vitamin B3, Vitamin C, Caffeine, Optic Brighteners For dark circles Scented $20.88 Buy on Amazon
Olay Regenerist Micro-Sculpting Eyeswirl 15 mL (0.5 fl oz) Vitamin B3, Vitamin B5, Amino Peptide Anti-aging Fragrance-free $20.70 Buy on Amazon
Olay Eyes Pro Retinol Eye Treatment 15 mL (0.5 fl oz) Pro-Retinol, Vitamin B3, Vitamin B5 For crow’s feet Fragrance-free $15.98 Buy on Amazon
Olay Eyes Deep Hydrating Eye Gel 15 mL (0.5 fl oz) Vitamin B3, Hyaluronic Acid, Cucumber Extract, Witch Hazel For tired eyes Fragrance-free $21.99 Buy on Amazon

1. Olay Eyes Ultimate Eye Cream

  • Retail Price: $39.95 (Click here to check the latest promotion)
  • Available Size: 13 mL (0.4 fl oz)
  • Key Ingredients: Vitamin B3, Amino Peptide, Pigments
  • Benefits: For dark circles, wrinkles, and puffiness
  • Fragrance: Fragrance-free

Instant results! That’s what Olay Eyes Ultimate Eye Cream promises. It features 3-in-1 benefits that make it the most popular among Olay’s eye products. Simultaneously fighting dark undereye circles, fine lines, and puffiness, it’s super convenient and easy to use.  It only takes a few seconds out of your daily beauty routine, and you can rest assured that it gets to work on all your eye area concerns.

The cream contains vitamin B3 (also known as niacinamide) to plump your skin and blur those pesky wrinkles. Amino peptides boost collagen production to make you look firmer and smoother. Finally, iron oxides are added for a subtle tint—giving you a touch of concealer that masks discoloration.

2. Olay Eyes Brightening Eye Cream

  • Retail Price: $20.88 (Click here to save up to 16%)
  • Available Size: 15 mL (0.5 fl oz)
  • Key Ingredient: Vitamin B3, Vitamin C, Caffeine, Optic Brighteners
  • Benefit: For dark circles
  • Fragrance: Scented

If your primary concern is dark circles that make your eyes look sunken, then Olay Eyes Brightening Eye Cream is the best product for you. Dark circles occur because of dilated blood vessels showing through the thin undereye skin. Olay uses caffeine to constrict these blue and green blood vessels, brightening your gaze. They also included a light-reflecting complex that makes you look well-rested and refreshed.

This cream has Vitamin C, a powerful antioxidant that protects you from the sun’s harmful rays and other environmental factors. It prevents oxidative damage that can cause elasticity loss and wrinkles. Moreover, it reduces melanin production to fend off hyperpigmentation, leading to a more radiant appearance.

Eye-Brightening Cream

You can tell your eyes exactly what to say about how you feel. Olay Eyes Brightening Eye Cream hydrates skin and brightens eye contours by evening skin tone and illuminating skin for eyes that look bright and well rested.

Look Bright-Eyed

With continued use morning and night, Brightening Eye Cream reduces the look of fine lines and wrinkles over time.

What’s Inside

Formulated with Vitamin C, Pro-Vitamin B5, Vitamin E Antioxidant Complex & Optic Brighteners, this eye cream helps to brighten skin and visibly improve dark circles and discoloration. It nourishes the eye area to help smooth lines and illuminate your eyes to match your smile.

3. Olay Regenerist Micro-Sculpting Eyeswirl

  • Retail Price: $20.70 (Click here to save up to 14%)
  • Available Size: 15 mL (0.5 fl oz)
  • Key Ingredient: Vitamin B3, Vitamin B5, Amino Peptide
  • Benefit: Anti-aging
  • Fragrance: Fragrance-free

Who doesn’t love an anti-aging product? The truth of the matter is, you are aging every day, so doesn’t it make sense to use skincare that can help you maintain your youth? Olay, the frontrunner in this area, actually popularized the term “anti-aging” when they launched their Regenerist boutique line in 2003. One product in that line, Olay Regenerist Micro-Sculpting Eyeswirl, visibly improves the texture of your undereye skin for a more youthful appearance. The “swirl” is a dual-phase formula that combines a hydrating gel with a firming cream.

This fast-absorbing recipe is safe to use, not just under the eyes, but also on the eyelids. With every application, you can feed your skin with panthenol (vitamin B5) to keep it soft and smooth. By enhancing the skin’s natural barrier, it shields you from DNA-damaging toxins and pollution. It also quenches dryness by absorbing moisture directly from the air.

4. Olay Eyes Pro Retinol Eye Treatment

  • Retail Price: $15.98 (Click here to save up to 47%)
  • Available Size: 15 mL (0.5 fl oz)
  • Key Ingredients: Pro-Retinol, Vitamin B3, Vitamin B5
  • Benefit: For crow’s feet
  • Fragrance: Fragrance-free

When it comes to wrinkle prevention, experts agree that the most effective ingredient is retinol. Olay Eyes Pro Retinol Eye Treatment takes this miraculous substance and puts it in a handy little tube for you. In just four weeks, it can reduce the look of your deepest wrinkles such as crow’s feet and squint lines.

Wrinkles are a sign that your skin has lost the ability to renew itself. As skin matures, it loses collagen, a protein that’s responsible for providing structure and firmness. Decreased collagen means decreased elasticity—your skin becomes thinner and less able to bounce back from constant movement like facial expressions. This retinol eye cream can stimulate collagen production to make up for that loss. At the same time, it also corrects uneven texture and age spots.

5. Olay Eyes Deep Hydrating Eye Gel

  • Retail Price: $21.99 (Click here to save up to 12%)
  • Available Size: 15 mL (0.5 fl oz)
  • Key Ingredients: Vitamin B3, Hyaluronic Acid, Cucumber Extract, Witch Hazel
  • Benefits: For tired eyes
  • Fragrance: Fragrance-free

Olay Eyes Deep Hydrating Gel can wake up your eyes to combat the signs of fatigue and sleepless nights. It contains sodium hyaluronate, a concentrated humectant that draws moisture into the skin and locks it in. It’s like a water magnet that replenishes your undereye area with 24-hour hydration.

This luscious blue gel also has cucumber extract to alleviate dryness and irritation with a cooling sensation. Witch hazel, a skin-toning ingredient, calms inflammation. It’s also an effective treatment for eye bags and puffiness. With all these nourishing elements, it’s no wonder that this product has outperformed more expensive eye creams in clinical tests.

The skin around your eyes has one of the weakest moisture barrier, often causing fine lines to appear there first. The Olay Eye Collection is specifically formulated for the delicate eye area. Get a targeted solution that rejuvenates your eyes—with concentrated benefits that an eye treatment can deliver.

Its fast-absorbing formula, supercharged with hyaluronic acid, peptides, pro-vitamin B5, witch hazel and cucumber extract, quenches skin for long-lasting hydration. The cooling gel hydration is the best way to wake up tired eyes—instantly plumping and smoothing the under eye area for a refreshed look.

Easy on the salt! When you take in too much sodium or not enough water, your body naturally holds on to excess fluid to help prevent dehydration, potentially causing your eyes to look fatigued.

Invest in an Olay Eye Cream to Look Your Best

No one ever wants to look like they’re tired, didn’t get enough sleep, or—perish the thought—getting older. That’s why Olay created a load of products to target the eyes. The delicate undereye area is the first to show signs that you aren’t at your best. Wrinkles, dark circles, puffiness? Invest in an Olay eye cream and say goodbye to these issues. Say hello to a youthful, energized you.