You might think you’ve already perfected your skincare routine. You use a gentle cleanser and moisturize your skin religiously. You’re even a firm believer in never going out without sunscreen. There’s just one thing you haven’t done, though. Applying eye cream. Whether you don’t have an eye cream or forgot to put it on, the truth is your eye area needs special care so that you can always look your best.

But where to start? There are so many eye products with wildly different prices, all promising to get rid of wrinkles, puffiness or dark circles. Our advice is to look towards a brand that you can trust. Recommended by dermatologists, non-irritating, and with a good price point. We’re talking about Neutrogena, of course.

5 Best Neutrogena Eye Creams

These five products from Neutrogena manage your undereye skin concerns gently yet effectively. All of them have lightweight non-oily formulas that are appropriate for any skin type. Plus, they’re fragrance-free to prevent irritating even the most sensitive skin.

  Product Available Size Key Ingredient Benefits Price    
Neutrogena Hydro Boost Eye Gel-Cream 0.5 oz Hyaluronic Acid For smoothing fine lines and wrinkles $14.97 Buy on Amazon  
Neutrogena Hydro Boost City Shield Eye Serum 0.47 oz Hyaluronic Acid, Antioxidants, Multivitamins For reviving pollution-stressed eye area $14.28 Buy on Amazon  
Neutrogena Rapid Wrinkle Repair Eye Cream 0.5 oz Retinol SA, Glucose Complex, Hyaluronic Acid Anti-aging $17.97 Buy on Amazon  
Neutrogena Healthy Skin Eye Cream 0.5 oz Alpha Hydroxy, Multivitamins, Melibiose Anti-aging $10.24 Buy on Amazon  
Neutrogena Rapid Dark Circle Repair Eye Cream 0.13 oz Accelerated Brightening Complex For brightening dark circles under the eyes $17.72 Buy on Amazon  

1. Neutrogena Hydro Boost Eye Gel-Cream

  • Retail Price: $14.97 (Click here to save up to 21% )
  • Available Size: 0.5 oz
  • Key Ingredient: Hyaluronic Acid
  • Benefits: For smoothing fine lines and wrinkles

The skin under your eyes is thinner and more delicate than the rest of your face. That means it isn’t able to retain moisture efficiently and is more prone to dryness. Chronic dry skin affects elasticity, leading to lines and wrinkles. Neutrogena Hydro Boost Eye Gel-Cream addresses these problems with a unique dual-action formula. It absorbs quickly, like a gel, for instant hydration. At the same time, it delivers the long-lasting moisturizing power of a cream.

Like all other products in Neutrogena’s Hydro Boost line, the star ingredient is hyaluronic acid. It’s a clear lubricating substance that’s produced naturally by your body. As you age, however, the amount of HAA declines. Environmental factors like pollution and the sun take their toll, too.

The gel-cram augments the hyaluronic acid in your skin, maintaining its supple look and feel. If you’re looking for a simple, no-frills product that works hard, this one fits the bill.

2. Neutrogena Hydro Boost City Shield Eye Serum

The main difference between an eye cream and an eye serum is that a serum penetrates the skin faster and easier. The latter releases its active ingredients in a more concentrated form, as is the case with Neutrogena Hydro Boost City Shield Eye Serum. Each application transports potent antioxidants that fight the skin-damaging effects of free radicals. Vitamins such as niacinamide and panthenol nourish your skin to make it look brighter. And of course, it’s got the ultra-hydrating abilities of hyaluronic acid.

What does pollution-stressed mean, exactly? You might not be aware of it, but you’re constantly bombarded by environmental aggressors. There are toxins in the air (free radicals) that can attack your skin and cause dullness and dryness. The skin around your eyes is particularly vulnerable. You could end up looking tired and listless all the time, no matter how much rest you get.

This product nips that type of damage in the bud. A single pump of this non-greasy, non-sticky serum under each eye twice a day provides effective protection. You’ll feel revitalized and refreshed as well.

Dot serum around eye area and smooth into skin until thoroughly absorbed.

Best if used in the morning.

Can be worn under or over makeup.

3. Neutrogena Rapid Wrinkle Repair Eye Cream

  • Retail Price: $17.97 (Click here to save up to 10%)
  • Available Size: 0.5 oz
  • Key Ingredients: Retinol SA, Glucose Complex, Hyaluronic Acid
  • Benefit: Anti-aging

The signs of aging might be inevitable, but it is possible to keep them at bay. Neutrogena Rapid Wrinkle Repair Eye Cream uses retinol to give you visibly younger-looking skin in just one week. Their patented Retinol SA (“SA” stands for sustained action) recipe works for a full 12 hours to diminish the appearance of fine lines and wrinkles. It also corrects dark circles under the eyes and age spots to make you look more wide-awake and youthful.

Retinol, a derivative of vitamin A, causes skin cells to turn over faster so that new skin cells can emerge. The results of this process are a smoother texture, clearer skin, and the fading of hyperpigmentation. Retinol also stops collagen breakdown to give your skin more elasticity and fullness. It’s especially beneficial for minimizing crow’s feet—those lines in the corners of your eyes.

Because retinol can sometimes cause skin to dry out, Neutrogena added glucose complex to this cream. It helps to condition your skin as it gets used to the retinol. Together with hyaluronic acid, it halts inflammation and moisturizes your undereye area.

4. Neutrogena Healthy Skin Eye Cream

  • Retail Price: $10.24 (Click here to save up to 21%)
  • Available Size: 0.5 oz
  • Key Ingredients: Alpha Hydroxy, Multivitamins, Melibiose
  • Benefit: Anti-aging

If you want an anti-aging eye cream but aren’t keen on retinol, a great alternative is Neutrogena Healthy Skin Eye Cream. This treatment employs glycolic acid, a member of the alpha hydroxy acid (AHA) family, that’s made from sugar cane. Its main function is to exfoliate the skin, removing the dead cells that make it look rough and dry. The result is increased luminosity and smoothness.

Glycolic acid can also stimulate collagen production. As your skin matures, it loses a protein that provides structure and firmness—that’s collagen. AHAs tell your skin to manufacture more, plumping and blurring the fine lines around your eyes.

Finally, this cream contains melibiose for extra hydration. Its water-binding properties form a protective layer to prevent your makeup from drying out your skin, making it ideal to use as a primer.

Retinol

Formula contains Retinol to work deep within skin’s surface where wrinkles develop

Vitamins

Formulated with Pro-Vitamin B5, Vitamins A & E

Alpha Hydroxy Acid

Formula contains Alpha Hydroxy Acid (AHA) a skin care ingredient to help reduce the appearance of fine lines.

5. Neutrogena Rapid Dark Circle Repair Eye Cream

  • Retail Price: $17.72 (Click here to save up to 16%)
  • Available Size: 0.13 oz
  • Key Ingredient: Accelerated Brightening Complex
  • Benefits: For brightening dark circles under the eyes

One of the most common complaints about the eye area is dark circles. Your undereye skin is so thin that sometimes, blood vessels can show through it. This could happen when you’re tired and stressed, but for some people, it’s a matter of genetics. Either way, Neutrogena Rapid Dark Circle Repair Eye Cream can help you.

It has a blend of light-diffusing minerals that can brighten up the eyes. Some consumers reported that they don’t even have to use concealer anymore because the skin tone is immediately more even. “Raccoon eyes” lightened significantly with regular use.

You’ll love its super convenient packaging. It’s shaped like a pen with a brush tip for easy application. A few swipes and you’re all set.

Your Eyes Deserve to Look Their Best

Now that you know about Neutrogena’s eye creams and what they can do for you, there’s no excuse for not using one. The skin under your eyes is more fragile and sensitive than the rest of your body. It deserves the same amount of attention, if not more. Daily use of a great eye treatment will make you look younger and more energized. You’ll wonder why you didn’t do it sooner.